Immigration from the Source

Yet all the great programs of the union can not change the fact that
work on the banana plantation is brutally hot and dangerous. SITRABI
members receive a little more than Guatemala’s minimum wage, about $6
US a day.  They may also live on the plantation's small houses (shared
between two often large
families) rent and utilities free.  There is a school and daycare for
the children, healthcare facilities, and a small pension for retirees.

The members of SITRABI have a good relationship with their employer,
Del Monte, but highly complex issues that workers have little influence
over could soon affect their jobs.  Banana trees can be moved from
Guatemala plantations to take advantage of cheaper (and un-unionized)
labor in South American countries like Brazil or Ecuador. Complex
international trade policies have encouraged some companies to go to
Africa.

Without their jobs, SITRABI members will share the same fate as the
majority of Guatemalans.  Eighty percent of the population lives in
poverty.  This kind of destitution fuels migration.  Currently,
remittances to Guatemala from immigrant family members in the US make
up more than its exports.   

Recently, with a decrease in demand and production, SITRABI members had
little choice but to support a new contract Del Monte signed with
Wal-Mart. Unfortunately, it has increased the number of bananas that
workers must box per hour—from 30 to 44—but with no additional pay.
This is beyond the capability of some, mostly older women, workers.
The union reports that this year, 90 of the members who lost their
jobs, took their severance pay and immigrated to the US.

In addition to hard work, poverty and low pay, violence is a part of
daily life for unionist in Guatemala.  As recently as 1999, five
SITRABI leaders were kidnapped and tortured by a town mob (some of whom
were identified as working for the company) when trying to organize a
strike protesting the lay-off of over 900 workers.  Last January, Pedro
Zamora was killed while driving home with his two young sons.  Zamora,
General Secretary of the Port Workers Union (STPEQ), was leading a
campaign to stop the government’s plan to restructure the Port of
Quetzal.  And two vendor union leaders were fatally shot on February 6,
2007.  No arrests have been made.

The U.S. had the opportunity with CAFTA to strengthen worker
protections and better conditions for Guatemala but failed.  The trade
agreement could have compelled signing countries, including Guatemala,
to adopt basic workers’ protection laws established under United
Nations and International Labor Organization (ILO) conventions.  But
CAFTA only requires countries to enforce their own labor laws—laws
judged by the ILO as weak and inadequate to protect workers.

In the midst of immigration battle in this country, it’s important to
look at what drives people to risk their lives, tear their families
apart, and gamble all the money they have, to come to the US.  Some of
it is poverty but some of it is horrendous exploitation, ignored, and
sometime supported, by our own trade policies and corporations. Good
jobs and protections for workers guaranteed by a fair trade policy
would allow workers to support their families, wherever they live.

Comments

re: Immigration from the Source

Excellent take on the terrible problems haunting the CAFTA agreement. This report is so well written, I wish it could be sent out nationally. It might be a welcome tonic to the current climate of immigant bashing in our country.

It appears to me that this cooperative trip was time and money well spent! Bravo to Ms. Riley and the other members of this team!

Elizabet Burr

re: Immigration from the Source

Thank you for bringing to light an example of how our trade policies are often at the root of immigration. Corporate driven trade policy forces U.S. workers to compete with superexploited workers overseas and then exploits them again when they migrate to the U.S. by pitting immigrant workers against native born workers. Who wins at every point of this vicious cycle? Corporate interests.

All unions must continue the struggle for trade policies that puts workers' interests, U.S. and foreign based, at the forefront. This should be coupled with a united effort on immigration reform based on the same principles. One without the other is not enough.

Thanks again!!

re: Immigration from the Source

I didn't realize how much globalization affects countries who depend on only a few exports in their economy. I may be misinformed, but I thought Guatemala had a fair-trade policy on coffee beans. How can this happen in some industries, yet be avoided in others? And as a recipiant of these goods, how can I make a difference?

re: Immigration from the Source

Brava! for Ms. Riley for her succinct, eloquent description of workers' enormous difficulties in Guatemala, and the adverse impact they have on the realities of immmigration to the USA. Thank you!

Jim Link

re: Immigration from the Source

Hi, all - Thanks so much for you kind comments on this article. STITCH was really happy to work with Denise and partner with her on her trip to Guatemala. I just wanted to follow up with Eddie and his question about coffee. When goods are certified as fair trade, like coffee, it is certified on a company-basis. So you could be buying coffee from Guatemala that is certified as fair trade but that only means the one farm that produces for that one company has that certification. There are, unfortunately, still many farms and factories in Guatemala that exploit their workers.

As a consumer who is interested in these issues, we always suggest that you contact those companies (like banana companies) and the stores where you buy goods (like grocery stores and big box stores) to let them know that you are very concerned about worker's rights and hope that they take positive action to support their workers, including paying a fair price to the producing factory or farm.

Thanks for your interest! Beth

re: Immigration from the Source

Bravo. There will only be justice for workers when more reporters like Denise Riley go into the horrible workplaces around the world and report their finding. Truth on the ground trumps speculation. David Waugh, Alliance for Retired Americans

re: Immigration from the Source

Thank you for writing this compelling account of labor practices in Guatemala. If only ALL Policy makers and those who are ignorant of the plight of foreign workers could read this and understand the impact of our trade policies. Please try to get this published in the lay press. What can we do as consumers?