These arguments are based on outdated assumptions and broad generalizations about the role of labor in economic development. In fact, organized labor often plays a positive role in economic growth, undergirding greater political stability, workshop discipline, and smart growth policy contributions. Governments need to reexamine economic policies that assume a relationship between economic development and labor repression, and adjust policies to reflect current reality.

The situation in China is ripe for such regulations.  Workers earn little, for starters.  According to Guangdong government statistics, in 2007, the average salary of migrant workers in the Pearl River Delta was 1,290 RMB or roughly $189 migrants make up the vast majority of the region’s factory employees.

The "Buy American" movement that has accompanied the push for economic stimulus has created space for discussing fundamental changes to the rules that have gutted local economies. At its best, this movement is inspired by a sense of solidarity with American workers, caring for our neighbors, and a genuine desire to revitalize local economies. At its best, the movement's message does not stop at "Buy American," which right now could include underground factories in Los Angeles or New York City where U.S.

ILRF's list of companies is titled "Working for Scrooge: 5 Worst Companies for the Freedom of Association."  The companies that made this year's list include:

Nestlé
A trusted family-brand in the U.S., Nestlé’s true impact overseas
involves a long history of union intimidation and ties to murders of
trade unionists.